Teach Me

What’s the Difference Between ILD, COPD and Asthma

Asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and interstitial lung disease (ILD) can all cause breathing problems. All three can cause shortness of breath, wheezing, coughing and chest tightness. But each requires a different approach to care. 

If you have trouble breathing, you probably have questions about what is causing it. Sachin Chaudhary, MD, a pulmonologist with Banner - University Medicine, explains the difference between asthma, COPD and ILD, including symptoms to watch for and how doctors tell these conditions apart.

Why breathing problems can be hard to compare

Breathing problems don’t always follow a pattern. Shortness of breath and cough can happen with many lung and heart conditions. Allergies, infections, acid reflux and other health problems can also cause similar symptoms.

Some breathing conditions develop slowly. You may not notice a change at first. Instead, you may gradually stop doing activities that once felt easy. Other conditions, such as asthma, may cause symptoms that come and go.

“The tempo and character of the symptoms matter more than the symptoms themselves,” Dr. Chaudhary said. 

The main difference is what part of your lung is affected:

  • Asthma: The airways become inflamed and narrow.
  • COPD: Airflow becomes blocked over time, making it harder to move air out of the lungs.
  • ILD: Changes to the lung tissue can make it harder for oxygen to move into the blood.

Because these symptoms can overlap, testing is often needed to find the cause.

What is interstitial lung disease?

Interstitial lung disease (ILD) is a group of over 200 lung conditions that cause inflammation or scarring in the lungs. When the lungs are inflamed or scarred, they become less flexible. It also gets harder for oxygen to pass into your blood.

According to Dr. Chaudhary, ILD usually causes breathlessness during activity that slowly gets worse over months or years. It can also cause a dry, nagging cough but no wheezing.

ILD is less common than asthma or COPD, so your doctor might not consider it first. Still, if you have symptoms that don’t align with other conditions, it’s important to get checked.

What is chronic obstructive pulmonary disease?

Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a long-term lung disease that blocks airflow. It includes emphysema and chronic bronchitis.

COPD often develops slowly. You might notice you're short of breath when walking, climbing stairs or doing other activities.

Smoking is a major risk factor for COPD but you don't need to smoke to get it. Long-term exposure to secondhand smoke, workplace dust or chemicals, air pollution or smoke from biomass can also increase the risk. Some people also have a genetic risk.

What is asthma?

Asthma is a chronic lung condition that causes inflammation and narrowing of the airways. 

“Symptoms of asthma are episodic and variable, so they can come and go,” Dr. Chaudhary said. “Patients have good days and bad days.”

Asthma symptoms may be worse at night or early in the morning. Triggers include allergies, exercise, cold air, smoke, respiratory infections and weather changes. Some people have few symptoms between episodes. Asthma affects both children and adults and can be diagnosed at any age.

Key differences: ILD vs. COPD vs. asthma

It can help to think about these conditions by looking at the pattern of your symptoms and what's happening in your lungs. 

Main problems:

  • ILD: The lung tissue gets inflamed, scarred and damaged, which can make it hard for oxygen to move.
  • COPD: Airflow gets blocked, making it difficult to blow air out of the lungs.
  • Asthma: The airways become inflamed and narrow, making it harder to breathe.

Symptoms:

  • ILD: Symptoms usually grow slowly and may get worse over time.
  • COPD: Symptoms happen gradually and can become more serious as time passes.
  • Asthma: Symptoms come and go and are often triggered by certain things.

Cough:

  • ILD: The cough is usually dry and lasts a long time.
  • COPD: The cough may bring up mucus or phlegm.
  • Asthma: Coughing might happen at night, in the early morning or after exposure to something that triggers it. 

These are general patterns, not a way to diagnose yourself. A dry cough doesn’t automatically mean ILD and a cough with mucus doesn’t automatically mean COPD.

Clues that may make your provider consider ILD

Your provider may consider ILD if you have:

  • Shortness of breath that steadily gets worse
  • A persistent dry cough
  • Increasing fatigue or lower activity tolerance
  • Symptoms that don't improve as expected with usual treatment
  • A history of an autoimmune disease
  • A family history of pulmonary fibrosis
  • Exposure to birds, mold, dust or certain workplace chemicals
  • A history of taking certain medications that can affect the lungs

Dr. Chaudhary said he also asks about symptoms outside the lungs, such as joint pain or swelling, Raynaud’s phenomenon, dry eyes or mouth, rashes, muscle weakness, reflux and trouble swallowing.

Clues that may make your provider consider COPD

COPD may be considered if you have ongoing breathing symptoms and a history of smoking or long-term exposure to lung irritants.

Possible clues include:

  • Shortness of breath that gets worse with activity
  • A chronic cough
  • Mucus or phlegm
  • Wheezing or chest tightness
  • Frequent respiratory infections or bronchitis
  • Symptoms that gradually worsen
  • Flare-ups when symptoms suddenly become worse

Clues that may make your provider consider asthma

Your provider may consider asthma when your symptoms vary or are linked to certain triggers.

Possible clues include:

  • Symptoms that come and go
  • Wheezing or chest tightness
  • Symptoms that are worse at night or early in the morning
  • Symptoms triggered by allergies, exercise, cold air, smoke or illness
  • Symptoms that improve with asthma treatment
  • Few or no symptoms between episodes

How do doctors tell the difference?

Your provider will start by asking about your symptoms and medical history. Be prepared to discuss when your symptoms started, whether they're getting worse and what makes them better or worse.

Your provider may also ask about:

  • Smoking or vaping
  • Secondhand smoke
  • Work and environmental exposures
  • Family history of lung disease
  • Medications
  • Autoimmune conditions
  • Allergies and other health conditions

You may also have a physical exam so your provider can listen to your lungs, plus other pulmonary and asthma screenings like:

  • Lung function tests: This may include spirometry, lung volume testing and diffusing capacity.
  • Medical imaging: Chest X-ray or CT scans to look for changes in your lungs.
  • Blood work or autoimmune testing (when appropriate)

If your symptoms are ongoing, unexplained or getting worse, your provider may refer you to a pulmonologist, a doctor who specializes in lung conditions.

When should you see a doctor for breathing problems?

You should also talk with a provider if you have:

  • Shortness of breath that limits walking, stairs, exercise, work or daily activities
  • A cough that lasts several weeks
  • A dry cough that doesn't go away
  • A cough with mucus that keeps returning
  • Wheezing or chest tightness
  • Symptoms that don't improve with your usual treatment
  • Frequent respiratory infections
  • New breathing problems if you smoke, used to smoke or have ongoing exposure to dust, chemicals, mold or smoke

Dr. Chaudhary says if you become breathless doing an activity you could easily do six to 12 months ago, you should get checked. He also recommends seeing a doctor if a cough lasts more than eight weeks.

When do breathing problems need urgent care?

Call 911 or go to the emergency department for:

  • Severe shortness of breath
  • Trouble speaking because of breathing problems
  • Blue or gray lips or face
  • Chest pain or pressure
  • Confusion
  • Fainting
  • Severe weakness
  • Coughing up blood
  • Sudden, severe worsening of your breathing

Severe breathing symptoms with fever or other signs of infection also deserve prompt evaluation.

Bottom line 

ILD, COPD and asthma all cause shortness of breath and cough but they affect the lungs differently. Asthma often causes sudden episodes of airway tightening. COPD leads to long-term airflow problems and usually includes a mucus cough. ILD damages lung tissue and may cause slow, worsening shortness of breath with a dry cough. Because these symptoms overlap, the best next step is a medical checkup and lung tests. 

Find a Banner Health specialist.

FAQs

How do I know if I have asthma, COPD or ILD?

You can't tell just from symptoms. A provider will review your symptoms, medical history and tests to find out what's causing your breathing problems.

Can ILD be mistaken for asthma or COPD?

Yes. ILD can be confused with asthma, COPD or other issues because shortness of breath and coughing is associated with many health problems. This is especially true during the early stages of ILD.

What is the main difference between COPD and ILD?

COPD mainly blocks airflow over time, while ILD damages lung tissue and makes it harder for oxygen to enter the blood.

What is the main difference between asthma and COPD?

Asthma symptoms come and go and can be triggered by allergies, exercise or cold air. COPD symptoms are more constant and may include a chronic cough with mucus.

Can asthma turn into COPD or ILD?

Asthma does not become ILD. Asthma and COPD are different but some people have both conditions. Your provider can find out what's causing your symptoms.

When should I worry about shortness of breath?

Talk to a doctor if you have lasting or worsening shortness of breath that affects your daily activities. Get emergency help if you experience severe breathing problems, chest pain, blue lips or face, confusion, fainting, coughing up blood or sudden worsening symptoms.

Related articles:

Pulmonology and Asthma