Protein is having a moment. You can find it in shakes, bars, cereals and snacks, almost anywhere. People use protein powder to build muscle, lose weight, gain weight or just get more protein during the day.
But do you really need protein powder? And if you choose to use it, how do you pick the right one?
“Protein powder can help but it’s not essential for good health," said Jacquelin Danielle Graham, RD, CSCS, a sports dietitian-nutritionist at Banner Sports Medicine. “Most people who casually exercise can get enough protein by eating normal meals and snacks."
Foods like eggs, dairy, fish, chicken, meat, beans, lentils, nuts and soy all have protein and other nutrients. Still, some people find protein powder helpful if they struggle to get enough from food alone.
If you are thinking about using protein powder, here’s what to know: when you might need it, how to use it safely and what to check on the label.
What is protein powder?
Protein powders are dietary supplements that provide concentrated protein in powdered form. They can be made from animal or plant sources, including:
- Whey and casein: Milk-based proteins
- Plant-based proteins: Such as soy, pea, rice and hemp
- Collagen: A protein supplement that is different from traditional protein powders because it does not contain all the essential amino acids
- Protein blends: Products that combine several protein sources
Some products contain little more than protein and flavoring. Others include added sugar, artificial sweeteners, vitamins, minerals, herbs, caffeine or other ingredients. That’s why two products labeled “protein powder” can differ greatly.
Are protein powders safe?
Protein powder isn’t automatically dangerous but supplements are not risk-free. What’s in the product matters, as does how much and how often you use it.
“Dietary supplements are not approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for safety and effectiveness before they are sold,” Graham said. “Products can also contain ingredients that are not obvious from the marketing on the front of the package.”
That makes choosing a product carefully important.
Look for third-party testing
Product quality can vary. Some products may contain contaminants, inaccurate amounts of ingredients or ingredients that aren't obvious from marketing. Third-party organizations can test supplements to verify they contain what the label says and screen for contaminants or substances that shouldn't be there.
Certifications to look for include:
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Informed Sport
- USP Verified
Third-party testing does not guarantee that a product is right for you. It provides another layer of quality control. This is especially important for competitive athletes, who may need to be particularly careful about ingredients that could violate sports organizations' banned substances rules.
Check the other ingredients
Protein powder is not always just protein. Depending on the product, it may contain ingredients that can cause problems for some people.
“For example, lactose in whey concentrate, sugar alcohols, gums and some plant proteins can cause bloating, gas or diarrhea,” Graham said.
Some products also contain large amounts of caffeine, stimulants, herbs or other ingredients that you may not need.
If you develop digestive symptoms after using a protein powder, check the ingredient list. You may tolerate a different protein source or formulation better.
Who might benefit from protein powder?
“You may not need a protein supplement if you are already getting enough protein from a balanced diet,” Graham said. “Many people can meet their protein needs through food.”
But protein powder may be useful if you have trouble getting enough protein from food alone. You might consider one if you:
- Have higher protein needs because you are very physically active
- Are working to maintain or build muscle along with strength training
- Are an older adult with a low appetite or concern about losing muscle
- Are recovering from an illness, injury or surgery and your health care team recommends more protein
- Have a busy schedule and need a convenient option
- Follow a vegetarian or vegan diet and have trouble getting enough protein from food
“The key question to ask yourself is, ‘Am I consistently meeting my protein needs or would a powder make that easier?’” Graham said. “The goal is to get enough protein for your individual needs and not to consume as much as possible.”
Who should be more cautious?
Before adding a protein supplement, talk with your health care provider or registered dietitian before using protein if you:
- Have kidney disease or reduced kidney function
- Have liver disease
- Are pregnant or breastfeeding
- Have diabetes or concerns about blood sugar
- Have food allergies or intolerances
- Have a digestive condition that makes certain ingredients difficult to tolerate
- Have a history of disordered eating
- Are undergoing cancer treatment or managing another complex medical condition
- Take several medications or other supplements
- Are considering protein powder for a child or teen
Some protein powders also contain herbs, stimulants, caffeine and other ingredients that may interact with medications or may not be appropriate for certain health conditions. The FDA recommends talking to your provider before using dietary supplements because of possible risks and interactions.
How much protein do you really need?
The amount of protein you need depends on more than your body weight. Your age, activity level, health and goals all play a role.
“For healthy adults, the recommended dietary allowance (RDA) for protein is 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight per day, which is about 0.36 grams per pound,” Graham said. “But I do not want people to look at that number and stop there. That is the RDA for the general population and it can be too low for people who are physically active.”
Graham recommends these general ranges:
- Active adults: 1.2–1.4 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day
- Endurance athletes: 1.2–1.6 grams per kilogram per day
- Strength and power athletes: 1.6–2.0 grams per kilogram per day
- During fat loss or a calorie deficit: 1.6–2.2 grams per kilogram per day
- Athletes over age 60: 1.6–2.2 grams per kilogram per day
Your protein needs can also change depending on how much you eat and when you eat it. Spreading protein throughout the day, particularly near when you exercise, can help support muscle repair and recovery.
If you're unsure how much protein you need, a registered dietitian can help you determine a goal based on your activity level, health and personal goals.
How to read a protein powder label
When choosing a protein powder, don’t let the marketing on the front of the package fool you. Turn it around and read the label.
Graham said to look for:
Protein source: Check whether it contains whey, casein, soy, pea, rice, hemp, collagen or a blend.
- Protein content: Look at the grams of protein per serving.
- Serving size: Find out how many scoops make one serving. One serving may mean one scoop, while another product may consider two or more scoops a serving.
- Added sugar: Some protein powders contain more added sugar than you might expect. Keep it under six grams per serving.
- Sweeteners: Artificial sweeteners and sugar alcohols can cause bloating, gas or diarrhea in some people.
- Calories: This is especially important if you are watching your overall calorie intake.
- Fiber: Some products contain fiber, while others contain little or none.
- Sodium: Check the amount if you are limiting your sodium intake.
- Allergens: Look for milk, soy, eggs, nuts, wheat or other ingredients you need to avoid.
- Extra ingredients: Be cautious with added caffeine, stimulants, herbs and other “performance” ingredients you do not need.
- Third-party testing: Look for independent testing or certification.
- Expiration and storage: Follow the product's expiration date and storage instructions.
Whey, plant-based protein, collagen or a meal replacement
Not all protein products are the same:
- Whey protein comes from milk and contains all nine essential amino acids. It is a convenient option if you tolerate dairy but it may not be appropriate if you have a milk allergy or are lactose intolerant.
- Plant-based protein powders can be a good option if you avoid dairy. Blends can provide a broader mix of essential amino acids.
- Collagen is not a complete protein because it does not contain all essential amino acids. It should not be your main protein source if your goal is to support muscle growth or maintain muscle.
- Meal replacement shakes are different from basic protein powders. They may contain protein along with carbs, fat, vitamins, minerals and more calories. If you use a shake in place of a meal, check whether it actually provides balanced nutrition.
There is no single best protein powder for everyone. Your choice depends on your goals, dietary needs, allergies and health.
Takeaway
Protein powders can be useful but they are not necessary for everyone. Food should come first because it offers more than just protein.
Talk to your doctor or a registered dietitian before trying a protein supplement. If you decide to use one, check the type of protein and how much is in each serving. Watch out for added sugar, sweeteners, allergens and extra ingredients. Pick products with third-party testing when possible and be careful of those that guarantee quick results.
Find a Banner Health registered dietitian.
FAQs
Is it safe to use protein powders every day?
Many healthy adults do. Whether you should depends on the product, how much you take, what's in it, your health and your overall diet. If you use protein powder often, talk to a health care provider or a registered dietitian.
Is whey protein better than plant-based protein?
Not necessarily. Whey is a complete protein and easy for people who can tolerate dairy. Plant-based protein may be better for those who avoid dairy. Your allergies, diet, tolerance and goals will help you decide which to choose.
What should I avoid in protein powder?
Watch for high amounts of added sugar, allergens, ingredients that upset your stomach, caffeine or stimulants and products without third-party testing. Be especially cautious of products making extreme health or performance claims.
Can protein powder help with weight loss?
It may help some people meet their protein needs or feel satisfied between meals, but protein powder is not a weight-loss solution on its own. Your overall eating pattern, activity, sleep and health needs matter.
Can teens use protein powder?
Yes, in some cases. Teens should get most of their protein from food but a protein powder may be appropriate if they cannot meet their needs through food alone, such as after practice or when appetite is low. Choose a powder with no more than 20 grams of protein per serving and combine it with carbohydrates for recovery. Talk with a pediatrician or registered dietitian to determine whether you need a supplement.
Does protein powder help you build muscle or gain weight?
Protein is essential for building and repairing muscle but protein powder alone won't build muscle. Strength training, enough calories, carbohydrates, protein, sleep and recovery all work together. A protein shake can help you meet your protein needs and, when part of an adequately fueled diet, may also support healthy weight gain.